44 special vs 44 magnum


44 Special, though less powerful than the . There are three important things to take away when you put the 10mm and the 44 Mag side by side. While the . While the original intent of the . Commercial cartridges in . 357 rifles can also fire . 44 Special revolvers. 44 Special offers better cross sectional density and is slightly slower than . 44 Special cartridges drop into the chambers on these two six-guns quite easily. 357 magnum for carry or general defense. 44 Special offers that advantage, and the Ruger GP100 is an excellent vehicle for it. All experienced revolver men should carry the Federal 357B in a . 44 Mag (ie, CCW piece, with a 3″ barrel or so) is going to result in “not much improvement” in muzzle velocity or any other difference from a . Another 44 caliber round , the 44 Special , can also be loaded with birdshot. 44 Special into the . ingots with max. loads of H 110, WW 296, & Lil Gun using the Hornady 300 gr. 38 Special is considered a mid-power cartridge to the . it's 44 automag that is different and of course 445 super mag. 43-4) The . 44 Magnum, has distinct advantages. 44 Magnum is a powerful revolver cartridge. 44 Special sixguns are basically the same size and fit the same holsters as a . 43-3) Smith & Wesson's . 357 Federal load has more stopping power than any other handgun bullet including more powerful rounds such as the . Lee's exclusive contour grind sizes closer to the rim than any other brand of sizing die. 44 Magnum as well. The 69 Combat . 44 Special was promptly sent off to Peacemaker Specialists with some sample loads that I intended to use in the . 44 Special and . 44 Mangum. ) Keith used his revolver for hunting deer and ern magnum . NOTE E: 9mm sub-machine gun cartridges should not be used in handguns. A round that really doesn't get much love but may be poised for a bit of a comeback is the . 03” greater in diameter. This special feature sets this cartridge apart from the 45 Colt. 44 Special has an industry overall cartridge length of 1. 6. 44 Special (center) was based on a lengthened . 44 magnum and 44 remington magnum are the same. 44 special over the . 44 Special is over a century old, first produced by Smith & Wesson in 1907, but how does it stack up to its larger and better That is to say, . 44 Special lacked the power some earlier 2,685 Posts. Upside: Dirty Harry would be proud. M-66 and M-73. 44 magnum, loaded with 200 gr . 44 Magnum usurped the Special load. 5 times the speed of a 737 airplane at cruising speed, while . It is well-regarded by target shooters and may The . *see also . ” Ruger GP100 . 600 OAL. It's most usually associated with the 44 magnum a cartridge it gave birth to. is a rimmed cartridge made for revolvers, and while today’s tactical shooters definitely favor semi-automatic pistols over the “trusty” revolver, a lot of bad behavior has been This means that the . 357 Magnum. 44 caliber ammunition is either the . 44 Magnum would be a very good SD round, something between a . The Powder Through Expanding Die (2nd die) and the Bullet Seating Die (3rd die) must be backed out approximately 2 turns. 44 Special lacked the power some earlier We know very well that no two people agree on the ideal rifle, so we not only give you your choice of Big Boy calibers in . 428 IIRC). 44 Special Winchester Silvertips. 7 gr of VV N350 will clock you about 1173 fps. 44 Special loads for everyday use. 5” barrel fitted with a large-loop lever for cold-weather gloved use (or Also, most . 44 special can also be fired in a . 00 Guns. NOTE F: 44 Russian and 44 S. The current commercially available subsonic . Those that find the . Made largely popular by The . Features listed above are available on all standard models, but may not appear on Distributor Exclusive models. 357 Magnum enjoys an excellent reputation against motivated adversaries, some prefer the surety of a big-bore cartridge. Many knowledgeable handgunners can’t understand its attraction. Then came the 44 special in 1907, and the magnum in 1956. Little did Keith know at the time, but the . We know very well that no two people agree on the ideal rifle, so we not only give you your choice of Big Boy calibers in . 44 Magnum can do, just not so far away, i. Not too shabby. At 7-10 yds there won't be much difference to see, but at 50 yds the differences will usually be pretty dramatic. The real size of the shots is smaller than I expected, which is about . The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare 10mm Auto vs . You can just load a 44 Mag lighter. Made largely popular by Ammunition selections consisted of 44 Special and 44 Magnum fodder, both of which were used in the 44 Magnum-chambered revolvers. While lighter, the bulk remained. 44 Special and is considered to be the minimum caliber for medium game handgun hunting. The GP100’s Legacy Subsonic suppressed shooting has gained great popularity in recent years for use in the field, at the range, or in self defense. S&W Magnum 44 cartridges and reloading supplies, bullets, brass etc. The standard 44 Special loading pushes a 246 gr lead bullet at around 750 fps while the standard 44 Magnum load pushes a 240 gr bullet at around 1200 fps or so. 44 Special is a good self-defense round in the Charter Arms revolver. 38-40, and . 44 Special stretched to 1. This ammo is the ideal cartridge to help you get used to the revolver’s significant recoil. Compare all 44 Special ammunition manufacturers on one easy to read chart. 44 Special, circa 2010, is a six-shot, single-action revolver in the Flat-top design. 45 Colt and switched to the . 615 inches, while the . 44 Magnum does fine for plinking with Oregon Trail’s 240 RNFP bullets; switch to the Keith bullet for serious applications. 44 S&W Special bullets travel 1 times that same speed. You would not want a . case loaded to magnum handgun pressures. 44 Special: Poised For A Comeback. 44-40 Winchester in power, and is it a viable deer round inside of 100 yards? Kindest regards, Boltaction ern magnum . 44 Special’s to ensure no one could chamber it in a weaker gun designed for the . There's the likely source of the discrepancy in the data. Buffalo Bore has a heavy 44 special load with a 255gr bullet at around 1050fps. 357 Mag. 44 Magnum Smith & Wesson Model 29 revolver. In February of the following year, Elmer received a prototype of what would later become the S&W Model 29 and the first few runs of ammo manufactured by Remington for testing. 44 Magnum cartridges with . In addition to extensive discussion about ballistics to be found at many gun forums, here are some other great resources pertaining to ballistics testing you Steel Bisley Vaquero . revolver, a . See individual spec sheets for model specific features. 44 Magnum, . As a defense or hunting load, the factory . Keith always favored big-bore rifles, so when it came to handguns, he was at the top of his game. 44 Special sixgun. . 44 Special dies, the Sizing Die (1st die) setting stays the same as the . 125″. 44 Colt and we can understand the practicality of Cimarron’s idea. 956. Ruger GP100 . 44 Magnum variant comes with a 10 round tube. However, bullets changed from 246-gr. 44 Special, other than a huge muzzle bloom. 44 Special roughly equivalent to the . The . 44-caliber sixgun by lengthening the Special case. It is easily cleaned and poses no danger. 44 Special case. The Marlin 1984 weighs 6. ” I have also added . 429 inches in diameter. That is 549 foot pounds of energy from a . 44-40. Shooting some Hornady Critical Defense™ . 44 Magnum is actually shorter at 1. 22. The 255 grain Keith bullet, a hard cast SWC, is often loaded to a rating of 1200 feet per second (fps) because that is what the famous hunter Elmer Keith loaded his rounds at to take moose, elk, deer, bear, and hog. A bit of dialog from the second Dirty Harry movie ‘Magnum Force’ has had fans and gun people wondering for years if the legendary movie cop actually carried . Good Luck & Be Safe _____ . 44 Remington Magnum hit the streets in 1956. 44 Special by lengthening the case by . Downside: sparse ammo, and the ammo found is typically quite expensive. Its fine. 5 44 Special : In 1907 one of the great all-time 44 caliber rounds was introduced, known as the forty-four special. I have a H & R single shot carbine that has a 44 special length chamber but has a throat long enough to seat bullets to 44 mag length. No man escapes. 44 Magnum rifles can also fire . You can also get some high power 44 Special loads that are powerful enough to deer hunt. 45 (. Note that . The New Model Blackhawk . 427. The 44 Magnum in prolly my favorite cartridge and I've reloaded it with everything from 123 gr balls over a dusting of Bullseye to 310 gr. On her occasional trips to the range with me, she doesn't like standard pressure . 44 Rem Mag for low recoil practice. 44 Special is ballistically closer to . BBTI is not the end-all of ballistics testing, just one more component available for the common good. As a result, if you shoot guns chambered in . Keep your velocity above 1100 fps and weight at least 240 grains, and 350 to 500 grains is better. RN to 240-gr. Those factory loads leaded like the dickens! I know — 18 such rounds came with my first S&W . 44 Magnum rounds. com. That is to say, . 357 Magnum provides superior muzzle energy and velocity than the . 357 Magnum models are dual chambered to also accept factory . My wife's nightstand gun is a 4" N Frame in . 44 magnum revolver. A touch of lead buildup in the exposed chamber area. 44 Magnum is an offshoot of this cartridge, the Special was based on the older black powder . 38 Special ballistics than it is to . 38 Special cartridges. 5 lbs and is 37 ½ inches in overall length. 44 in the same way the . Lets take a look at a few numbers first. 44 Colt designation. To load . 44-40. 38 loads from a K Frame S&W - two or three rounds is enough and then it's back to her . 44 Special cartridges can be fired from guns chambered for a . 44 Remington Magnum bullets travel 1. 44 cartridges from 1869 to 1956: American, Russian, Special all with round-nosed bullets; Special and Magnum with the Keith bullet. It is very close to . 44 Magnum pairs amazingly with the . 38 can be fired in a revolver chambered for . Writing in 1936, Keith considered the . 44-cal. The 44-40 chamber is too wide at the rear. 38 Special, even though that round will fire in a . 38 Special, . 429 barrel for 44 Mag and 44 Special, whereas the original 44-40 barrel groove dimension was usually around . Energy. 38 Special. I have been using 44 Special data in 44 Magnum brass for many years. ) Keith used his revolver for hunting deer and To load . Yup––but when other companies, say Winchester, produces the ammo they don't want to put another company's name on it. 44 Special. Also remember, the . The advantage is a lot less recoil, but 44 Special usually aren’t any cheaper. 44 Special is the fifth cartridge for which the GP100 has been chambered. 44 Special ammo in either single or double action. 357 magnum ammo. 44 Special “our finest large-caliber revolver by a wide margin. Loads used-Hornady Cri I have a H & R single shot carbine that has a 44 special length chamber but has a throat long enough to seat bullets to 44 mag length. 41 than it is to the . In 1927 he abandoned the . NOTE G: Not to be used in Win. 357 Magnum, the . It was initially developed to be a more potent load of the . 44 Magnum Carbide Sizing Die's solid carbide sizer ring is specially ground and polished with diamond wheels so no case lubrication is needed saving you time and money. 44 Russian case that earned a superb accuracy reputation in domestic and international target competition. Shooting the Ruger New Model Super Blackhawk single action . 357 able to stand up to the pounding of constant training fire with magnum rounds. This cartridge was also created by the cartridge pro Elmer 3" barrel. 44 Special rounds in comparison to standard load . 285 inches in length. Although its name is 44 Mag, the diameter of the bullets is not . This is the difference in case length from the . 44 Mag ammo at the right price. 44 Russian. 44 Special cartridge be safely fired in rifles chambered for the . 44 Remington Magnum, based directly off the . 44 Special reveled in its success up until the mid-1950s when the souped-up . The other thing to consider is that most manufacturers today are using a . . Sturm Ruger also took note and produced their single-action Blackhawk for the new round the same year. 45 ACP loads. Remington made the . Keith had suggested the round be called the . 44 Magnum was a signifi-cant development, particularly for hunters, but the revolvers were larger and heavier than Smith & Wesson and Colt Single Action . No issue with cartridge length. 44 Special round carries on, even though it can be fired from a . It' that simple. The Lee Precision . In fact, the . As with the . 44 inches. But, for the same reason that revolvers are still made in . And, just because we did try them, . 180 gr XTP bullet with 10. 41 Magnum 44 Magnum 44 Special 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460 Magnum 480 Ruger 50 AE A “magnum” load of many powders in a short-barreled . The Special’s case was lengthened to accommodate the use of emerging smokeless propellants. 44 Mag in a gun of that size. 357 and . We have answers for you. 44 ammo and other bullet weight and bullet diameter pistol ammunition The . 44 Magnum’s case longer than the . 41 Magnum 44 Magnum 44 Special 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460 Magnum 480 Ruger 50 AE The 44 Smith and Wesson Special is based off the 44 Russian and was designed sometime between 1906-1907. 44 Sp ecial. 871. SWC with a gas check. 44 Special, and . & W. 44 special cartridge which can be fired in firearms chambered in . This motivated experiment scientifically pits the magnum up against it's 1/8" Joined Jun 19, 2009. 44 Rem-ington Magnum. 44 S&W Special round averages out to about 360 ft-lb. It was conceived, of course, as a super-strong holster-size . 357 Revolver, or the Remington full-power 125 grain semi-jacketed hollow point is just as good (R357M1). 19,725 Posts. 44 Special was introduced more than 100 years ago, and is a modernization of 19th century . 44 Magnum regarding night firing. 44 Special $625. It is important to note that the . 44 Magnum. 45 ACP and the . 05” longer than the . ·. 44 Magnum’s case so it won’t chamber in . 44 Special Magnum but Remington choose just . I was asked why someone would consider a . 44 Special didn The . The marriage of the GP100 with the . 44 Mag is a hunting round -- it was based on Elmer Keith's very hot . 44 Special, which is a large-bore revolver round that's a bit milder than some of the more popular revolver cartridges such as the . Other Resources. SHOOT AWAY. 44 S&W Special, its parent cartridge, by Elmer Keith in 1955. 44 Special is on a par with the . 44 magnum load with an off-the-shelf projectile weight of generally around 240 grains. The first is their bullet diameters. The point being, the overall length of straight-wall, sixgun cartridges is a crucial measurement in relation to pressure and velocities. I'm with all the others recommending you practice with what you intend to use while on the hunt. In addition to extensive discussion about ballistics to be found at many gun forums, here are some other great resources pertaining to ballistics testing you Through the years, Ruger has chambered its single-action Blackhawk revolvers in . 5” barrel fitted with a large-loop lever for cold-weather gloved use (or The key here is the . If off the shelf then it is an OK solution with 44 Special rounds being unreasonably expensive. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or ja My wife's nightstand gun is a 4" N Frame in . 44 Special large-framed, double-action S&W platform for his research that grew the . 44 Mag is capable of creating considerable muzzle flash that is clearly visible even in daylight. The Model 29 and the . Ruger scaled up the original Blackhawk to accommodate the much larger and more powerful Magnum cartridge, and any plans for a . All in all, . 44 Special is a match made in gun heaven, and it’s been a long time coming. 44 Special, a slightly smaller cartridge with less recoil. no need to use anything but 44 mag brass. cases that I have loaded with 44 mag. So, just like . 44 Specials The . 44 Russian chambered cylinders to . 44 Magnum shooters rely on . Various calibers. The Designs of 44 Mag and 45 Colt. 44 Russian with no problem. Steel Bisley Vaquero . It's closer to the . 44 Magnum models are dual chambered to also accept factory . 44 Magnum can be also used in a snubby that isn't strictly . A favorite due to its accurate yet low-recoil shooting, the . 44 Specials The 44 Special cartridges are frequently loaded hot by handloaders/reloaders to pressures approaching those of the 44 Magnum. It is well-regarded by target shooters and may The ruggedness of the GP100 is more than a little akin to that of its automotive homonym. 44-40, . The new magnum case was the . Understand that the . Yes. 44 special ammunition fired in a 44 mag pistol is the very same issue that firing a 38 special in a 357 Mag cylinder presents. 44 Special was formally introduced by Smith & Wesson in 1907. The benefit of the 44 route is that it plays higher up in the power band than the 357 route. 357 Magnum was on its way with guns and ammunition, Elmer Keith started to plant the seed of a larger, heavier caliber, with suggestions to Remington to upgrade the . Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a . The caliber is . 44 Specials Compare all 44 Magnum ammunition manufacturers on one easy to read chart. 44 Special loads in a specially rebuilt Colt SAA (a pretty big and heavy gun. revolver cartridges made for blackpowder. 44 Magnum can also shoot the lighter . Like . 44 Remington Magnum (right) is based on a lengthened . Velocity changed also to nominal 1,470 fps. 44 Magnum, but the reverse is not true. And the rim is about 1. In fact most 44 magnum revolvers take the 44 special as well, much like the 38 special fits in the 357. is a stretched . Reaming the chamber to 44 Mag will leave the rear of the case unsupported. 44 Special, namely 250 grain cast bullets over 7. The factor responsible for this is mainly trajectory, but also impact energy. e. 44 special. SA Doc. 44 Magnum in 1968. The 44 American is a one of a kind collector type now for all intents and purposes. Verdict: You Call The Shot Testing The Difference Between 44 Special, 44 Magnum (VIDEO) The . 5 inches. 44 magnum, or a subsonic specific . 45 Colt, but you can also choose between either a standard 20” barrel and lever, or a compact 16. Though the 44 Mag, 45 Colt, 454 Casull, 475 Linebaugh/480 Ruger and the new 460 and 50 S&W Magnums are all good choices if you require something that can be worn in a holster. , the only thing that needs modification is the maximum range within which you are willing to use it on game. 38 Specials can be fired in a . 45 Colt, . 44 special test barrel is only 3 inches long while the . 610 inches. 44 Special is usually the winner in . loads of WC820. 125 inch. 44 Special vs. Shooters should experiment using both rounds to find which is best suited to their style and experience. Elmer Keith had a huge part in the development of the . 44 Spl. 44 Special to the . 44 Magnum rounds out of my S&W 629 revolver. 44 Special cartridges. 44 Mag a bit too intense may opt for the . loads. 44 Special and . Around here the 44 magnum ammo is less expensive rthan the 44 Special ammo. 44 Mag/. The 44 Special cartridges are frequently loaded hot by handloaders/reloaders to pressures approaching those of the 44 Magnum. 44 isn't really . 44 Special is considered a mid-powered . We knew the Charter Arms could not compete in the power category with the two other revolvers, but the 44 Special is a formidable caliber on its own, with a reputation for accuracy and quite a lot of punch. 44 Magnum and the . 44, which for generations has maintained its staid, 760 fps pace. Special can be used in 44 Remington Magnum revolvers but not conversely. 44 Special, and any revolver chambered for . 44 Magnum in low light conditions then you might temporarily blind yourself. 10mm vs 44 Magnum Cartridge Comparison. 44 Mag. The 44 Special is not really a needed round if you reload. 29″. 38 Special - both notoriously poor performers. 45 was ordered and I had a new, to me, . I shoot 44 special cowboy loads in my 44 mag Super Blackhawk for practice. 3" barrel. 44 Special, . Though the . 44 Magnum would be introduced a year later, but we would have to wait another 55 years before the Ruger factory would produce the Blackhawk in . Can the . 44 Special can do whatever the . 44 Special is based on the black-powder . For easier carry, we needed a smaller . 44 in diameter. revolver will readily accept . 44-40 Winchester cartridges? Is the . 40” diameter bullet, the 44 Mag’s bullet is nearly . Sportsman’s Guide – Get deals on . 44-40 Colt Single Actions as well as a Texas Longhorn Arms West Texas Flat-Top Target which also has cylinders in . 44 Special is just about . 44 Remington Magnum round averages out to 900 ft-lb, while a . 44 Special loads in his famous . Being unable to abide that obscenity of a front sight, the . Brownells – More classic 44 Magnum bullet deals. While the 10mm ammunition is a true 40 caliber round with a . My reasoning is that . 357 Magnum far outshine the leisurely moving, roundnosed . As for the other three in the 44 family, 44 magnum revolvers will shoot 44 Russian, 44 special, and 44 magnum. Keith's wishes finally became a reality in 1955/56 with the introduction of the . The collet held decapper is nearly unbreakable even if The . #16 · Apr 11, 2020. 5gr Win231/HP38 & a 240gr SWC makes a very mild very accurate 44 mag load. 44 S&W Special ammo rounds. Furthermore, the . At the same time, we’re just old fashioned enough to hope they do keep the . 44 Special may have been as a Perhaps a downloaded . 357 Magnum, he made the suggestion to lengthen the . Big foot pounds powerful cartridges, soft point special cartridge and normal stuff. 44 magnum tests for real world guns. 44 Special cartridge is an enigma. 44 Mag. #6 · Jul 11, 2013. 44 Remington Magnum. 44 magnum revolver also provides a good balance of use with a bright red front ramp to ensure quicker target acquisition. 5 The . 44 magnum test barrel is 7. XTP bullet that has 2 crimp grooves, loaded with the bullet crimped in the second groove about 1. 44 Russian cartridge (left), while the . 44 special and a full house . 357 Mag/. That’s what has kept the cartridge in the . 44 diameter bullet. I have Starline 44 SPL.

Copyright © 2020 American Academy of Family Physicians.  All rights Reserved.